I'm enjoying this beanie very much. I own several of each design. This one is thinner but I like it just fine and it feels great. I like the Murphy too. I recommend this for dressing up.
Originally bought this with the intention of rocking it during a trip to a colder area. Obviously it isn't meant for freezing cold temps, but it keeps my head and ears warm enough, and looks/feels amazing. Super light, breathable, and doesn't feel restrictive like a cap.